|
|
Post by Nahara46 on Sept 20, 2012 21:03:33 GMT -5
What instrument do you think each character would play? I imagine Ron on an upright bass  |
|
|
|
Post by physicssquid on Sept 20, 2012 22:43:50 GMT -5
I see Harry as a guitar-player, it doesn't matter whether it's lead guitar, rhythm guitar, or bass guitar, I just see him playing a guitar.
|
|
|
|
Post by brokenquill92 on Sept 20, 2012 23:16:18 GMT -5
Harry violin
Ginny acoustic guitar
Ron trumpet
Hermione clarinet
Dumbledore cello
Voldemort Baldwin piano
Sirius AC/DC
Remus smooth jazz
Tonks goth punk
Lily Potter lullaby
|
|
|
|
Post by Nahara46 on Sept 20, 2012 23:47:43 GMT -5
Ooh, I love Lindsey Stirling! Violin is definitely something I could imagine Harry playing, with how much you can move with it and such. This particular song isn't exactly what I would choose for him, but it would be alright. Elements seems to portray a lot of the... flow that magic has, which I think would go well with Harry. But I think that Harry would go well with a song that had a... darker section. Not a completely solemn song, but one that goes between free-spirited and the kind of trapped feeling music can give. Would work, thought I think she'd play something more upbeat or adventurous. Maybe Pirates of the Caribbean? Meh... I still have the upright bass in my head, but it's alright. Love the song choice, Hermione would most definitely play a classic of some type xD. Clarinet would really work for her, now that i think of it. (I don't normally think of wind instruments, they almost always escape my mind!) [/url][/quote] Meh... Cello? Honestly, if I think of Dumbledore in any musical sense, he's the conductor! He can't sit down, it doesn't seem like him, so piano is out. Hm... I'll have to think on him. Piano for Voldie- awesome! (As long as he doesn't start playing anything to upbeat and happy sounding  ). I think this song is good, better then anything I can think of! (The best I can think of is Ichabod's Walk, but I don't know if there's a piano version of that xD) Can't imagine Sirius doing absolutely anything else. I'm iffy on this one. Remus doesn't seem very.... smooth to me. That's more of the fanon Remus. I think he'd have to do something that would work with Sirius. Am I the only one who things that Tonks isn't at all goth-punky? She strikes me as a very optimistic and spontaneous person who is generally quite friendly and wouldn't really like goth-punk style music. (Though, Monochrome no kiss is one of my favorite songs!) If I had to choose, I think I'd give Tonks a Viola. Viola always struck me as the odd one out of the Violin, Cello, Viola and bass. I think Tonk would choose it just for the kicks of it being the odd one out. Plus, it sounds cool and could play any happy free-spirited song she wanted. [/quote] Hehe, i love this! Sounds very Harpy- which is what i was thinking for Lily. That and piano- not the creepy Voldie kind of piano, but a kinder and softer kind. Like you said- lullaby. |
|
|
|
Post by brokenquill92 on Sept 21, 2012 0:02:13 GMT -5
Ooh, I love Lindsey Stirling! Violin is definitely something I could imagine Harry playing, with how much you can move with it and such. This particular song isn't exactly what I would choose for him, but it would be alright. Elements seems to portray a lot of the... flow that magic has, which I think would go well with Harry. But I think that Harry would go well with a song that had a... darker section. Not a completely solemn song, but one that goes between free-spirited and the kind of trapped feeling music can give. Would work, thought I think she'd play something more upbeat or adventurous. Maybe Pirates of the Caribbean? Meh... I still have the upright bass in my head, but it's alright. Love the song choice, Hermione would most definitely play a classic of some type xD. Clarinet would really work for her, now that i think of it. (I don't normally think of wind instruments, they almost always escape my mind!) Meh... Cello? Honestly, if I think of Dumbledore in any musical sense, he's the conductor! He can't sit down, it doesn't seem like him, so piano is out. Hm... I'll have to think on him. Piano for Voldie- awesome! (As long as he doesn't start playing anything to upbeat and happy sounding ). I think this song is good, better then anything I can think of! (The best I can think of is Ichabod's Walk, but I don't know if there's a piano version of that xD) Can't imagine Sirius doing absolutely anything else. I'm iffy on this one. Remus doesn't seem very.... smooth to me. That's more of the fanon Remus. I think he'd have to do something that would work with Sirius. Am I the only one who things that Tonks isn't at all goth-punky? She strikes me as a very optimistic and spontaneous person who is generally quite friendly and wouldn't really like goth-punk style music. (Though, Monochrome no kiss is one of my favorite songs!) If I had to choose, I think I'd give Tonks a Viola. Viola always struck me as the odd one out of the Violin, Cello, Viola and bass. I think Tonk would choose it just for the kicks of it being the odd one out. Plus, it sounds cool and could play any happy free-spirited song she wanted. Hehe, i love this! Sounds very Harpy- which is what i was thinking for Lily. That and piano- not the creepy Voldie kind of piano, but a kinder and softer kind. Like you said- lullaby.[/quote]With Tonks I dithered between that and Gwen stefani , Dumbledore the multi player cello was just how I thought his mind worked, I'm trying to find something more subtle for Remus and Harry needs something with just a taste of dark |
|
|
|
Post by brokenquill92 on Sept 21, 2012 0:11:29 GMT -5
Remus and Tonks
|
|
|
|
Post by brokenquill92 on Sept 21, 2012 0:17:24 GMT -5
Ooh, I love Lindsey Stirling! Violin is definitely something I could imagine Harry playing, with how much you can move with it and such. This particular song isn't exactly what I would choose for him, but it would be alright. Elements seems to portray a lot of the... flow that magic has, which I think would go well with Harry. But I think that Harry would go well with a song that had a... darker section. Not a completely solemn song, but one that goes between free-spirited and the kind of trapped feeling music can give. Would work, thought I think she'd play something more upbeat or adventurous. Maybe Pirates of the Caribbean? Meh... I still have the upright bass in my head, but it's alright. Love the song choice, Hermione would most definitely play a classic of some type xD. Clarinet would really work for her, now that i think of it. (I don't normally think of wind instruments, they almost always escape my mind!) Meh... Cello? Honestly, if I think of Dumbledore in any musical sense, he's the conductor! He can't sit down, it doesn't seem like him, so piano is out. Hm... I'll have to think on him. Piano for Voldie- awesome! (As long as he doesn't start playing anything to upbeat and happy sounding ). I think this song is good, better then anything I can think of! (The best I can think of is Ichabod's Walk, but I don't know if there's a piano version of that xD) Can't imagine Sirius doing absolutely anything else. I'm iffy on this one. Remus doesn't seem very.... smooth to me. That's more of the fanon Remus. I think he'd have to do something that would work with Sirius. Am I the only one who things that Tonks isn't at all goth-punky? She strikes me as a very optimistic and spontaneous person who is generally quite friendly and wouldn't really like goth-punk style music. (Though, Monochrome no kiss is one of my favorite songs!) If I had to choose, I think I'd give Tonks a Viola. Viola always struck me as the odd one out of the Violin, Cello, Viola and bass. I think Tonk would choose it just for the kicks of it being the odd one out. Plus, it sounds cool and could play any happy free-spirited song she wanted. Hehe, i love this! Sounds very Harpy- which is what i was thinking for Lily. That and piano- not the creepy Voldie kind of piano, but a kinder and softer kind. Like you said- lullaby.[/quote]Is this more what you had in mind for Harry |
|
|
|
Post by Nahara46 on Sept 21, 2012 15:54:05 GMT -5
I love that new Tonks/Remus song! It really has a mix between what I think they'd both be . As for Harry's thing- My god that's a beautiful video, and the music sounds simple at times, but just what Harry would play! |
|
). I think this song is good, better then anything I can think of! (The best I can think of is Ichabod's Walk, but I don't know if there's a piano version of that xD)